Reviews
Our Story
In Newburgh, Indiana, the independent insurance agency Paradise Insurance Group, LLC services clients from all across Indiana and Kentucky. Our agency is 100% independent of any one firm, unlike captive or direct insurance companies that exclusively offer their own unique products. It is locally owned. When it comes to something as significant as insurance, many people do not completely comprehend how crucial that is. You must collaborate with a company that has in-depth expertise of numerous insurance products, businesses, and regulations—not just one.
Reviews
Justin did a fantastic job helping us switch our home and auto insurance. He was great to work with and very accommodating.
Jeremy was great! Knowledgeable and polite. A gentleman and a scholar!
We switched insurance companies and saved a substantial amount. I could not ask for a better person to help with this process. Very attentive to detail, very customer oriented! You are not just a number to Justin , he truly wants to help you and do the best for you! He is the best insurance person I have ever dealt with!
Went to a handful of other people to try to find the right coverage spent weeks without any luck. Then within a few hours Jeremey Davis got me hooked up with a great rate without any problems. If you’re looking for insurance he is the guy. By far made it easier then it’s ever been for me without question.
Very pleased with the cost, coverage and overall experience! Would definitely recommend Paradise Insurance
Jeremy worked to save me
a lot of money on my car insurance
While actually giving much more coverage
I would recommend anyone wanting to deal with a honest and great agent he’s your person
Rich Anderson
a lot of money on my car insurance
While actually giving much more coverage
I would recommend anyone wanting to deal with a honest and great agent he’s your person
Rich Anderson
Jeremy worked to save me
a lot of money on my car insurance
While actually giving much more coverage
I would recommend anyone wanting to deal with a honest and great agent he’s your person
Rich Anderson
a lot of money on my car insurance
While actually giving much more coverage
I would recommend anyone wanting to deal with a honest and great agent he’s your person
Rich Anderson
I was referred by a business friend a year ago to Paradise. My husband and I are so pleased with our Auto and Homeowner Insurance rates. But the personal service by our agent Austin was above and beyond! He's been very informative, guiding and helpful in answering all our questions. Glad we left the " big guys". Our rates our stable and affordable. Thank you.
Transferred my home and business to these amazing local people. Saved big money and they made the process nice and smooth. Highly recommend
Why Choosing a Local Insurance Agent is the Smartest Choice
I truly believe that going with a local company is always the better option. Why? Because big agencies tend to be pricey and raise their rates whenever they feel like it. On the other hand, local agents genuinely care about their clients and go the extra mile to help save money.
Paradise Insurance has been a game-changer for us, saving us more than half of what we previously paid for our vehicle insurance—and for that, we are incredibly grateful!
Recently, my car had some trouble due to bad weather (battery died), and Evansville’s own **Justin Connaughton** stepped in to help. He diagnosed the issue, removed the battery, drove us to a nearby store to get a replacement, and even installed it himself. That kind of service not only saved us money but also reminded us why supporting local businesses is so important.
A huge thank you to **Justin Connaughton** and **Paradise Insurance** for their outstanding service!
I truly believe that going with a local company is always the better option. Why? Because big agencies tend to be pricey and raise their rates whenever they feel like it. On the other hand, local agents genuinely care about their clients and go the extra mile to help save money.
Paradise Insurance has been a game-changer for us, saving us more than half of what we previously paid for our vehicle insurance—and for that, we are incredibly grateful!
Recently, my car had some trouble due to bad weather (battery died), and Evansville’s own **Justin Connaughton** stepped in to help. He diagnosed the issue, removed the battery, drove us to a nearby store to get a replacement, and even installed it himself. That kind of service not only saved us money but also reminded us why supporting local businesses is so important.
A huge thank you to **Justin Connaughton** and **Paradise Insurance** for their outstanding service!
Great experience and business All the way around highly recommend was a pleasure doing business with paradise group and Austin. Very helpful gentlemen
Jeremey did great! In less than 24 hours after messaging him, we had insurance at a rate better than we hoped for! Definitely recommend!
Top notch customer service, this team goes out of their way to make sure you are covered.
I'm very happy with Paradise insurance. The agent handling my coverage is friendly and willing to answer questions. It's a huge improvement over the service I received from the prior company I had insurance with.
Jeremy Davis has been my agent for years now. He's professional, prompt, and really puts in the hours for me to get the best coverage and prices available. I've spoken to a few others in the office and they've always been super relatable and helpful in anything I've needed. Definitely recommend this group.
Justin was very accommodating and saved me half of what was paying for insurance. Be sure to use him for all your insurance needs!!
I use Paradise Insurance for commercial insurance for my photography business. I worked closely with Jeremey to create the perfect coverage plan with the exact needs for my business. The customer care I have received from Paradise has been above and beyond, and the insurance rates they were able to find for me were fantastic. I highly recommend Paradise Insurance!
Justin @ Paradise has helped me tremendously. I highly recommend utilizing his knowledge. It's rare to find someone that takes pride in doing what's best for you not what's most profitable.
Jermey helped me and my customer and that had an accident with one of his customers and it was smooth process. Very easy to work with and very helpful.
Great experience all around! While shopping around for auto & home insurance with many different companies, Jeremey was the most responsive, providing quick and detailed information. He answered all of our questions (I had a lot) and sat down with me to explain all of the available options. He was very friendly and professional, and we are so grateful we signed with him!
CALL OR TEXT US TODAY!
(812) 674-9040